When Buffy and Willow next met, Buffy announced that Faith was back in Sunnydale. "I'm sure she'd like to join our spanking club. She prides herself on trying anything - 'kinks or vanilla'. And she seems to be reformed. I think we can trust her."
"I met a new recruit as well" said Willow. "She was at my Wicca group and kind of shy. Her name is Tara - and I'm not sure why yet, but I really really like her."
On the appointed Saturday, Willow introduced Tara to the other club members. Then there was a knock at the front door, and Faith entered in her usual black leather clothing.
"Well Faith, and Tara" said Willow, "the first step in your initiation is to check your health to ensure you can withstand our penalties. Buffy is our appointed medical officer." Both initiates guessed that this was a test to make sure they wouldn't refuse to take clothes off, or to be touched intimately.
"Tara first" Buffy continued. "But Faith, if that tight costume is awkward to take off, you'd better start working on it. Just the bottom half, if you please. Get bare from the waist down. Tara, we'll have that skirt and your top off instead." It was clear that Tara was bra-less.
The new recruits both looked a little quizzical at not being revealed in the same way. "Two things to remember" said Cordelia. "One, life isn't fair, as the cards or the dice will teach you. Two, you'll have to be obedient when you're the loser of a game."
"And new pledges are de-facto losers" added Fred, who had pledged a sorority back at UCLA and was disappointed to find that paddles were a thing of the past.
Tara was feeling sexually excited already. All the girls present had to be at least a little bit bisexual, to enjoy playing such games with other females. But Tara alone had no interest in men at all. She was a little shy about 'coming out', and her fantasies of being dominated, spanked and looked after by a strong woman were unfulfilled. She had no trouble obeying Buffy, and stripped to her sky-blue panties.
Buffy made a show of some cliche medical tests on Tara. "Open your mouth wide. Follow my finger with your eyes. Now let me feel your pulse." Her next move was going to be a breast examination, like a check for lumps. Tara's boobs were over average size, and well shaped. As Buffy reached for them, she was taken aback. The nipples were clearly erect, this early in the proceedings. "Is it cold in here?" she asked with a grin.
The others stepped forward for a closer look at what Buffy was talking about and started chuckling. Tara blushed crimson. "Don't worry, darling" laughed Willow. "That reaction is a pass, not a fail."
"Yes" said Buffy, "I don't think we need any more 'medical tests' for you, Tara. You may watch as we test your fellow initiate."
As she removed her pants, Faith had been watching and listening. "That girl didn't even get groped", she thought. Her black costume was sheer, and she had not worn any panties under it. So she was now half-naked, as ordered, not bothering to hide her dark triangle.
"Hands behind your neck, and step over here please, Faith" said Buffy. The formerly-rogue Slayer padded across the carpet, her nether regions on show for the five other women in the room. For her too, this Club was a wicked fantasy becoming reality, but she had liked watching Tara being made to strip more than having to do it herself. She was looking forward most to winning a game and having one of these girls over her knee.
Buffy went through her routine of innocuous medical tests as she had with Tara. "Fine, now up on the table, legs spread wide."
Faith hesitated. A gyno routine now, when Tara was hardly touched? But Cordelia simply said "Obedience!" to remind her. She sat on the table resentfully, slid back, then raised her knees and placed her feet wide apart on the table surface.
Buffy had no real intention of performing a very intrusive examination on her old sparring partner. Truth be told, Faith had already done enough to prove she could be submissive. But to be sure, Buffy touched her fellow Slayer's labia gently with her fingertips, and went "Hmmmm" like a stereotype TV doctor.
The "patient's" eyes went wide at the intimate touch. "My God, if anyone I knew in prison could see me now, playing Doctor!" she thought. "I refused to do it for THEM!" But it was completely different now nobody was trying to force her, and she had no regrets about being here.
"You may both dress" said Buffy. As Faith replaced her black pants and Tara put on the pastel-coloured clothes she favoured, Willow announced "You've both passed the lack-of-modesty test", and the four founder members applauded.
Willow explained the coming proceedings. "Our club is based on games and luck of the draw, so you won't both have to perform all the tests. For each ritual, the two of you will draw high-card, and the loser will have to endure the test. But if one of you gets two penalties in a row, the other must take the next one. Life has to be a LITTLE bit fair."
Tara and Faith looked at each other and grinned. "May the best woman win, and the other one suffer" said Faith. Tara could only blush again. She recognized a naturally dominant woman when she saw one!
"The ratio of pain to embarrassment will rise with each test" said Willow. "First, the loser must take a hand spanking, with her bottom bare, over the knee of our current newest member, Fred."
The thin studious girl gave them a shy smile, and set a pack of cards on the table. "Ace counts as low. Who will draw first?"
Faith's thoughts at that moment were "From fighting vampires to bare-bottomed over the lap of a skinny nerd like her? Please, no"! Whereas Tara was thinking "Fred is such a cute girl. I'm scared I'll get visibly wet if she spanks me!"
